OMARO · MORTGAGE INTELLIGENCE

Should You Buy or Rent? How to Compare the Real Costs

Buying and renting can both be sound choices. Here is how to compare the full monthly cost, the cash you tie up, and how long you need to stay.

Home Buying · Updated November 2026 · By Omaro Ayloush, Mortgage Loan Originator

There is no universal answer. Buying builds equity and gives you control of the property, but it ties up cash and adds costs that rent does not. Renting keeps you flexible and leaves maintenance to someone else. The useful question is what each option would cost you, in your situation, over the time you expect to stay.

Compare the full monthly cost

A mortgage payment is only part of what owning costs. Add property taxes, homeowners insurance, HOA dues if there are any, and an allowance for maintenance and repairs. A commonly used rule of thumb is to budget around 1% of the home’s value per year for maintenance, though older and larger homes can cost more.

Assume a $700,000 home with 20% down ($140,000), a $560,000 loan at an assumed 6.5% on a 30-year fixed rate (for the math only, not a quote), and rent of $3,000 a month for a comparable home.

Monthly costOwnRent
Principal and interest$3,540n/a
Property taxes (assumed 1.1% of price)$642n/a
Homeowners insurance (assumed)$150n/a
Maintenance (1% rule of thumb)$583n/a
Rentn/a$3,000
Totalabout $4,915$3,000

Owning costs about $1,900 more per month in this example. Part of that gap builds equity: roughly $6,300 of loan principal is repaid in the first year, while interest, taxes, insurance and maintenance are costs, much like rent.

Count the cash you tie up

In the example, the $140,000 down payment plus closing costs is cash that is no longer available as a safety net or for other goals. You will also want reserves for repairs. When you sell, you will usually have selling costs as well. Compare those up-front and exit costs with the monthly savings you expect, not just the payment.

Buy or rent: why time horizon matters

Buying costs money at the start and again when you sell, and it takes time to recover them. The break-even point depends on the price, the rate, rent changes and how local prices move, and none of those can be predicted. In general, the longer you expect to stay, the more owning tends to make sense. If you might move in a couple of years, renting may be the more flexible choice.

Questions to ask yourself

  • How long do I expect to stay in this area?
  • Could I handle the full monthly cost, plus a surprise repair, without strain?
  • Would the down payment still leave me a cash cushion?
  • Is my income stable enough for a long-term commitment?
  • Do I value control and stability more than flexibility?

Tax treatment of mortgage interest and property taxes varies by situation, so ask a tax professional how it applies to you.

Frequently asked questions

Is renting just throwing money away?

Rent pays for housing and flexibility, just as the interest, taxes, insurance and maintenance of owning do. Owning also builds equity as you repay principal, and it may benefit from appreciation, which is not guaranteed.

How much should I have saved before buying?

Enough for the down payment, closing costs and a reserve for repairs and emergencies. See Cash to Close Explained for what to expect at closing.

Can a lender tell me whether I should buy?

A lender can show what you may qualify for and what the payment could be. The decision to buy or rent also depends on your plans, which only you can weigh.

Want to see what this could look like for you?

Send your goals, rough budget and timeline. I can help you compare possible financing paths and the tradeoffs to consider. Please don’t send sensitive personal documents through an unsecured message.

Send me a message

Get my purchase options

Related reading: How Much Income Do You Need to Buy a House? · Cash to Close Explained · First-Time Homebuyer Programs

About the author: Omaro Ayloush is a Mortgage Loan Originator with West Capital Lending, Inc., helping borrowers explore home financing options in California.

Omaro Ayloush | Mortgage Loan Originator | NMLS #2036765 | DRE #02159573 | West Capital Lending, Inc. | NMLS #1566096 | DRE #02022356. Educational information only. Examples are hypothetical and are not rate quotes, offers or predictions. Program availability, eligibility, rates, fees and terms vary by borrower, property and lender. All loans are subject to underwriting and approval. Not a commitment to lend. NMLS Consumer Access.

OMARO AYLOUSH

Mortgage Loan Originator

NMLS #2036765  |  DRE #02159573

Powered by

West Capital Lending

NMLS #1566096  |  DRE #02022356

Equal Housing Lender logo

Send a Message

(323) 682-0044

17911 Von Karman, Suite 400
Irvine, CA 92614